Let’s consider two disciples in tandem. They’re Thaddaeus and Judas, the son of James. What makes them unique is that they didn’t make all four of the lists of disciples. Instead, they’re each referred to twice—not four times like Bartholomew, James, Simon, and the rest of the group.
Matthew and Mark both mention Thaddaeus as one of the twelve disciples. However, Luke omits Thaddaeus in both his books (Luke and Acts). Instead he includes Judas, the son of James, whom Matthew and Mark both omit.
Why the difference?
We’re left to wonder why the Bible has this discrepancy. It could be that Mark got it wrong and Matthew copied him. (Some Bible scholars believe the book of Mark was written first, and Matthew based his on it.)
Or it could be that Luke got the names wrong when he researched and wrote about Jesus and the early church.
Another possibility is that Thaddaeus starts out as a disciple but then leaves, with Judas, son of James, taking over.
A third explanation is that twelve isn’t a literal number but figurative. It could be there are twelve disciples, perhaps thirteen, or maybe even more.
A fourth option is that Jesus’s band of twelve is a dynamic group with people coming and going. Therefore, the roster changes over time.
Regardless, the Bible says that both Thaddaeus and Judas, son of James, are disciples. Let’s celebrate them as such.
How do we react when our name is omitted from a list of people serving Jesus or someone else’s name is inserted for the work we did?
[Discover more about Thaddaeus in Matthew 10:3 and Mark 3:18. Read about Judas the Son of James in Luke 6:16, and Acts 1:13.]
Read about more biblical characters in The Friends and Foes of Jesus, now available in e-book, paperback, and hardcover.
Come face to face with Christ’s closest followers as well as his most outspoken rivals in The Friends and Foes of Jesus. Be inspired to follow their successes and informed to avoid their mistakes.
Get your copy of The Friends and Foes of Jesus today!
Peter DeHaan writes about biblical Christianity to confront a status quo faith and live a life that matters. He seeks a fresh approach to following Jesus through the lens of Scripture, without the baggage of made-up traditions and meaningless practices.
Read more in his books, blog, and weekly email updates.